Jed Mahrle's Top 7 Email Templates for Sellers
Boost response rates with Practical Prospecting’s proven emails

Jed Mahrle
Magical for Email Prospecting
Share
Hey there, Jed here! There are a collection of email templates that my teams and I have personally employed and found to be quite effective, consistently yielding reply rates surpassing the 5% mark. A quick disclaimer: These examples are drawn from our practical experiences and have delivered results for us. However, they're not set in stone. Your task is to rework them to suit your audience and infuse them with your unique style. So, without further ado, feel free to explore, adapt, and make these templates your own. Enjoy the journey!
What templates are included in this Email Prospecting pack?
Ask for Feedback
When to use it: When your messaging isn’t working or you’re building your outbound messaging for the first time. It’s a great way to get your prospects to open up and share valuable information that will help you understand your market better. You’ll also find that it tends to open up conversations that lead to meetings anyway.
Breakup Email
When to use it: The last email in your sequence. Break-up emails are a debated topic but this one is worth testing because, at the very least, you’re getting valuable information on how to improve your messaging from the only source that matters… your prospects!!! And while, yes, this email is an ask without giving anything in return, the response rates tend to be high because people want to give you their expert opinion.
Bump with Social Proof
When to use it: As a bump email (response to a previous email) midway through your sequence. The goal is to build trust and credibility by providing a helpful resource, related to the problem you solve, from a source other than your own company (i.e. a 3rd party).
Ghost Follow-Up
When to use it: When a prospect no-shows you or is ghosting you mid-sales cycle. Have your manager send this one. The gift card sentence is optional. A/B test to see how it lands with your prospects.
OOO Reply
When to use it: When you get an “Out of Office” email reply. See if the prospect left the name of who to reach out to while they’re away in their email. Then send this template to that person.
Previous Company Referral
When to use it: We all get “Not interested” replies. Most people just ignore them or worse, try to handle the objection over email… when was the last time that worked??? Instead, look at the prospect's LinkedIn and find the last company they worked at. Then send this simple template with the goal of getting a referral to that company.
Reference Direct Reports
When to use it: When you’re sending an initial email to a prospect but can’t find anything relevant to personalize on. Find their direct reports on LinkedIn. Then frame your email around them to catch the prospect's attention.
More Email Prospecting packs
How do you personalize your Email Prospecting templates?
Magical allows you to personalize these templates with your recipients information like
First Name
Company
Direct Report
Solution
And move more types of information by creating your own custom labels.
How to use Email Prospecting templates
With Magical, you can save any text you type repetitively as a template in Magical and expand the template automatically when you work. Download our Sales prospecting templates to get these templates out of the box.
What is Magical?
Magical is a productivity app that automates your soul-crushing tasks so you can do the work that gets you promoted and still have time to take a break. With Magical, use AI to speed through repetitive tasks like messaging or data entry anywhere on the web —no fancy set-up required. Add Magical to your browser - it’s free.